Opting Out of Commercial Christmas
15 December 2007‘Tis the season, right? What does that mean to you? To me it means it’s the season to care for one another, help those less fortunate than ourselves (even more than the other 10 months of the year), and spend time celebrating the beauty of the wintertime, and share the company of friends and family. Cliché? Maybe. But not if you mean it and put it into practice.
This year we’re opting out of commercial Christmas. A catchy turn-of-phrase that describes the way we’re putting our idea of “’tis the season” into practice. Rather than take part in the shopping madness (like santa’s little elves at left) and buying many “things” for people because it’s just what we’ve always done, we took a different approach: making a gift for each person on our list.
Sure, there’s things you can buy that are meaningful: donations in their names to charities; practical gifts like gas cards or household goods; and experiences like gift cards to day spas or peticures. We’ve done that for the past few years (and will again in the future, I’m sure) but this year we’re taking a stand against rampant consumerism.
It’s interesting how difficult it is remain true to this principle. We talk about how we feel like we’re not getting enough stuff for our family and friends. It’s not that a hand-made gift doesn’t take effort and some money. But after years of buying a “big present” for everyone, along with lots of “stocking stuffers,” it’s hard to feel that the item we thought about, bought materials/ingredients for, worked for days to complete, and wrapped is enough. Kinda proves the point about our consumer culture running rampant.
So, take a look at your habits this year (or next, as it is only a week or so until Christmas and much of the shopping is already done) and see whether the person you’re buying for really needs it. We certainly don’t expect much and have encouraged our family not to “go nuts” on us; we’d appreciate any small gift or card and be content that it was given as acknowledgment of love and friendship. Unless you’re buying us iPhones; we really want those ;-)
Crystal wrote about this topic on our blog, www.CrystalAndScott.com. Check it out, if you’re not a member of a retail marketing federation or something who believes this sort of thinking is the end of world.






Unfortunately we live in a society where you need to
tannerellen | 22 December 2007 | 8:45 pmUnfortunately we live in a society where you need to buy lots of things for everyone to prosper. Our system is very capitalist and benefits greatly from consumerism. So basically, when our next recession hits, I am blaming you! It’s all your fault for not buying a ton of crap for christmas. Thanks for killing our economy!
I know you're joking (at least, I hope you are
scott.bush | 23 December 2007 | 11:32 amI know you’re joking (at least, I hope you are or you’ll kick my butt with some of that mixed-martial arts you’re so good at–my aikido won’t be able to defeat you! ;-) but I have thought about that. Sure, it’s fine if we opt out. It’d even be fine if a few hundred families did. Beyond that and yes, our capitalistic system may suffer to the point where real problems happen. But maybe that’s what we need?
The industrial revolution spurred change. It wasn’t easy, but it advanced us. Later, more and more automation cost jobs–but those jobs were replaced with a more knowledge-based workforce. Some would argue that the outsourcing of even knowledge-based jobs to global work centers like Bangalore is just another stage of our economic evolution. Similarly, maybe moving away from a consumerism-driven model is part of our advancement as a society?
Or perhaps it would just bring chaos the likes of which haven’t been seen since the scarcity of Tickle-Me Elmo dolls in 2003?
Yeah, I was just giving you a hard time.
tannerellen | 29 December 2007 | 2:23 pmYeah, I was just giving you a hard time. I wish I had the willpower to do what you guys did for christmas. It is really hard though when everyone else is out buying gifts and asking you what you want. It always makes me want to buy gifts and it gets me thinking about what I might want to buy for myself ; ) I think that we can only be one extreme or the other. Either our whole society needs to get rid of all possessions or we need to keep getting constantly more materialistic to support our growing population. I don’t think we could support a non-material society unless we had a huge collapse in population. Maybe if 3/4 of our population died then we would have the land and resources to support what was left. We would also have to stop living in cities and go back to living in smaller groups. Something to look forward to I guess. The closest thing we will probably see in our lifetime is Communism, unfortunately.
[...] you may have read elsewhere on teh Intarwebs, we
Scott Bush » Best.Present.Ever | 27 January 2008 | 12:39 pm[...] you may have read elsewhere on teh Intarwebs, we focused on homemade gifts this year. I’m pleased to report that our [...]